Vienna · Puglia

Insights

Succession in a Family Business: The Conversation Nobody Wants to Start

Ask the owner of a family business whether succession matters and the answer comes at once: of course. Ask when the family last sat down to discuss it and the answer slows. There is usually a reason. The successor is not quite ready, the market is difficult, this is not the year. Each reason is plausible. Over ten years, together, they form a pattern.

The puzzle is that decisive people, who plan acquisitions and investments years ahead, leave the one transition certain to happen unplanned. Research on family firms suggests this is less an oversight than an arrangement.

A conspiracy without conspirators

In 1988 Ivan Lansberg gave the pattern a name: the succession conspiracy. His argument was that resistance does not sit with the founder alone. The founder faces the loss of power and identity, and, without saying so, his or her own mortality. A spouse may fear losing a role and a way of life. Children may fear having to choose between siblings, or being chosen. Long-serving managers may fear losing the patron who protected them. Each party has private reasons to leave the topic alone, and together they produce a silence nobody has to defend, because nobody raises it. No one plots. The avoidance is shared and unspoken, which is what makes it so stable.

Three circles, one dinner table

Renato Tagiuri and John Davis at Harvard Business School described the family firm as three overlapping systems: family, business and ownership. A daughter can be family member, manager and future shareholder at once; a son-in-law may belong to the family and to none of the others. Each succession question reads differently from each circle. In the family, fairness often means treating children equally. In the business, it means choosing the most capable.

Tagiuri and Davis called the features of family firms bivalent: the closeness and long horizon that give these firms their strength are also the source of their hardest conflicts. Succession is where that bivalence becomes concrete. To raise it is to bring all three circles into one conversation, and that is the conversation each circle has reason to avoid.

A dance that needs two

Wendy Handler, studying successions in family firms, described the process as a mutual role adjustment. As the founder moves from sole operator to monarch, then to delegator and finally to consultant, the next generation moves from helper to manager to leader. The shifts have to happen together. A successor cannot step forward faster than the incumbent steps back, and an incumbent who waits for the successor to be ready may be waiting for something only the stepping back would produce.

Jeffrey Sonnenfeld's study of retiring chief executives, The Hero's Farewell, adds a sobering detail. Some leaders leave like ambassadors, gracefully and still available. Others leave like monarchs, only when death or a revolt forces them, or like generals, who go reluctantly and plan their return. The style of leaving says less about the successor than about what the role has come to mean to the person leaving it, a question explored in Who Are You Without the Title?.

A systemic view

Family therapists have long described obligations that pass between generations without ever being spoken. Ivan Boszormenyi-Nagy and Geraldine Spark called them invisible loyalties. A successor may accept the role out of loyalty to a parent, or decline it out of loyalty to a sibling. A founder may hold on out of loyalty to the parent who built the company first. Seen this way, the silence around succession is not a gap in a plan. It may be the family's way of protecting something it has not yet found words for.

When Alfredo De Massis, Jess Chua and James Chrisman reviewed why intended family successions fail, they grouped the causes into individual, relational, financial, contextual and process factors. Competence of the successor is only one strand among many. How the choice itself is made is the subject of Appointing a CEO or a Successor: What CVs and Interviews Miss.

These ideas are developed in Michele's book Leadership Coaching with Horses: The Power of Psychometrics and Biofeedback (Routledge, 2025).

Questions worth sitting with

  • If you had to name your successor tomorrow, whose reaction would you fear most?
  • What would you lose on the day you hand over that no contract could compensate?
  • Who in your family is keeping the silence, and what might they be protecting?
  • If the business were not in the family, what would you already have decided?

What the research suggests

Studies of family firms suggest that delay in succession is rarely about information or timing alone. It is often sustained by the whole system, founder, family, managers and owners, each with understandable reasons. Much of this work rests on case studies and surveys rather than controlled comparisons, and none of it shows that an earlier conversation guarantees a better outcome. It suggests only that the silence itself deserves attention.

Sources

  • Boszormenyi-Nagy, I., & Spark, G. M. (1973). Invisible loyalties: Reciprocity in intergenerational family therapy. Harper & Row.
  • De Massis, A., Chua, J. H., & Chrisman, J. J. (2008). Factors preventing intra-family succession. Family Business Review, 21(2), 183–199.
  • Handler, W. C. (1990). Succession in family firms: A mutual role adjustment between entrepreneur and next-generation family members. Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, 15(1), 37–52.
  • Lansberg, I. (1988). The succession conspiracy. Family Business Review, 1(2), 119–143.
  • Sonnenfeld, J. (1988). The hero's farewell: What happens when CEOs retire. Oxford University Press.
  • Tagiuri, R., & Davis, J. (1996). Bivalent attributes of the family firm. Family Business Review, 9(2), 199–208.

If this is familiar, write to Michele's office in confidence: info@nature-motivation.com. Every enquiry is read by Michele.

Free download

Questions worth sitting with

Twenty-four questions drawn from these essays on burnout, exits, succession and identity, as a short PDF. Leave your email and the questions are sent to you, together with a short monthly letter you can leave with one click.